Does Hagel's Memo require BCMRs to automatically grant upgrades to Vietnam Veterans with PTSD symptoms?

The assertion that BCMRs must consider but are not required to automatically grant upgrades to Vietnam Veterans with PTSD symptoms aligns with the guidance provided by Hagel's Memo. This memo emphasizes the need for a careful review of each case based on the evidence presented, taking into account the challenges that veterans may face, including the psychological impact of combat and service-related experiences.

This approach encourages a thoughtful and individualized assessment rather than a blanket policy that would mandate upgrades purely based on the presence of PTSD symptoms. It supports the idea that while PTSD may have influenced the character of discharge, the circumstances surrounding each veteran's service must be evaluated thoroughly. Therefore, the decision to grant an upgrade ultimately remains at the discretion of the BCMRs, allowing for a more nuanced understanding of each veteran’s unique situation.

Clarifying the other options, asserting that upgrades must be granted automatically does not reflect the intent of the memo, which advocates for consideration rather than automatic responses. Similarly, stating that it only applies to specific groups misrepresents the broader applicability to Vietnam Veterans suffering from PTSD. Finally, suggesting that upgrades are entirely at the board's discretion reflects a partial understanding, as it neglects the requirement for consideration put forth in Hagel's Memo.